Electronic Stopping Power of Matter for Ions

₃Li ions

Ag

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure.

Air

Graph

Data by Hv71 appear low

Al

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and origin plot.

Al₂O₃

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and origin plot.

Ar

Graph

Au

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin file.

B

Graph

C

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin file.

Here, many curves stay below the data at the maximum!

CH₄

Graph

CO₂

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and origin plot.

PASS too high at low energy

Cu

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and origin plot.

Gd

Graph

H₂

Graph

The complete data table (txt file)

H₂O, liquid

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and origin plot.

He

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and origin plot.

Data by Hv71 appear low. PASS too high at low energy

Kapton (polyimide)

Graph

Complete data table (txt file), origin figure

Kr

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), origin figure

LR115

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), origin figure

Lu

Graph

Mylar

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), origin figure.

N₂

Graph

Ne

Graph

The complete data table (txt file).

Data by Hv71 appear low. PASS too high at low energy

Ni

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and the origin figure

O₂

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and the origin figure

Pd

Graph

Polycarbonate

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin file.

Polypropylene

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure.

Si

Graph

Complete data table (txt file), and origin figure.

SRIM13 and MSTAR describe most of the data. The CasP 5.2 curve is low for energies below the stopping maximum. BA09 data is included only for E>50 keV/amu as requested by the authors.

Silicon nitride

Graph

Complete data table (txt file), origin figure

SiO₂

Graph

Ta

Graph

Ti

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Toluene

Graph

Xe

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), origin figure

Zn

Graph

The complete data table (txt file),

Click here to get all the ORIGIN files for Li ion.

All data for Li ion is here, even those not plotted yet.

₄Be ions

Al

Graph

The complete data table (txt file). Data by Ang00 is high compared to Zha02b

Au

Graph

The complete data table (txt file).

C

Graph

The complete data table (txt file).

Fe

Graph

The complete data table (txt file).

He

Graph

The complete data table (txt file).

Nb₂O₅

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), origin figure

Ne

Graph

The complete data table (txt file).

Ni

Graph

The complete data table (txt file).

Si

Graph

The complete data table (txt file).

SiC

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), origin figure

SiO₂

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), origin figure

Ta₂O₅

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), origin figure

Zn

Graph

The complete data table (txt file).

ZrO₂

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), origin figure

Here is the universal plot for Be ions. Click here to get all the origin files for Be ion.

All data for Be ion is here, even those not plotted yet.

₅B ions

Ag

Graph

Air

Graph

Al

Graph

Ar

Graph

Au

Graph

Data by Bt65 low compared to other data

B

Graph

C

Graph

Gd

Graph

Kapton (polyimide)

Graph

Get the complete data table (txt file), get the origin figure.

Only data by Rä90. Excellent agreement of SRIM13

Mylar

Graph

N₂

Graph

Ni

Graph

Data by Bt65 low compared to other data

Poly carbonate

Graph

Si

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and the origin figure.

Silicon nitride

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and the origin figure.

TiN

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and the origin figure.

Zn

Graph

Here is the universal plot for B ions. To get the ORIGIN files, click here to get all the ORIGIN files for B ion.

All data for B ion is here, even those not plotted yet.

₆C ions

Ag

Graph

Air

Graph

Al

Graph

Al₂O₃

Graph

Ar

Graph

The MSTAR curves follow the data points very well

Au

Graph

B

Graph

Be

Graph

Note the remarkable discrepancy between the (only) two data sets for C on Be!

C

Graph

SRIM, ATIMA, PASS and MSTAR curves fit the data quite well, the Konac curve (KO98) does not (at high energy because of the chosen I-value).Belowthe maximum, Geant4 becomes unreliable. CasP fits well except at low energy

Cu

Graph

Ge

Graph

Get the complete data table (txt file), get the origin figure. SRIM13 and MSTAR do not describe the data

Graphite

Graph

H₂

Graph

H₂O, liquid water

Graph

He

Graph

Kapton (polyimide)

Graph

Get the complete data table (txt file), get the origin figure

LR115

Graph

Get the complete data table (txt file), get the origin figure

Mylar

Graph

Get the complete data table (txt file), get the origin figure

N

Graph

Ni

Graph

Get the complete data table (txt file), get the origin figure. The data by Hu00 are too high, different from all the rest.

Polycarbonate

Graph

PVC

Graph

Si

Graph

Silicon nitride

Graph

Get the complete data table (txt file), get the origin figure

Silicon dioxide

Graph

Ta

Graph

Ti

Graph

Get the complete data table (txt file), get the origin figure. SRIM13 agrees with recent data Msi15

Zr

Graph

ZrO₂

Graph

Here is the universal plot for C ions. To get all the ORIGIN files for C ions, click here

All data for C ion is here, even those not plotted yet.

₇N ions

Ag

Graph

IDSA Data by Zi87 extrapolate to finite value for v=0: strange!
libdEdx, Jav12 and MNCPX are too low

Air

Graph

Al

Graph

Sa91 and Na68 data appear too high

Al₂O₃

Graph

Get the complete data table (txt file), get the origin figure

Ar

Graph

Data by Fu96 very low compared to Or68, We53

Au

Graph

Nd77 data appear too steep

C

Graph

Cu

Graph

IDSA Data by Zi87 extrapolate to finite value for v=0: strange!

Ge

Graph

H

Graph

He

Graph

N

Graph

Kr

Graph

Mylar

Graph

Ne

Graph

Ni

Graph

IDSA Data by Zi87 extrapolate to finite value for v=0: strange!

Polycarbonate

Graph

Get the complete data table (txt file), get the origin figure

Si

Graph

SiC

Graph

SiO₂

Graph

Ta

Graph

Ti

Graph

TiN

Graph

Get the complete data table (txt file), get the origin figure

Xe

Graph

Here is the universal plot for N ions. To get the ORIGIN files, click here.

All data for N ion is here, even those not plotted yet.

₈O ions

Ag

Graph

Air

Graph

Al

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and the origin figure.

Al₂O₃

Graph

Ar

Graph

Au

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and the origin figure.

The new data by Trz18 corroborate previous stopping values around the maximum, above the theoretical predictions and above SRIM and MSTAR.

B

Graph

Be

Graph

Note the remarkable discrepancy between the data sets Ch68 and Sa92, similar to the case of carbon ions on Be!

C

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and the origin figure.

The new data by Trz18 seems to correct previous data by the same group.

Cu

Graph

Formvar

Graph

the complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Ge

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and the origin figure.

H₂

Graph

the complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

He

Graph

the complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

In

Graph

Kapton (polyimide)

Graph

the complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

LR115

Graph

the complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Mylar

Graph

the complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

N₂

Graph

Nb₂O₅

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and the origin figure.

Ne

Graph

Ni

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and the origin figure.

Nice theoretical-experimental agreement.

O₂

Graph

Polycarbonate

Graph

the complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Polypropylene

Graph

the complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Si

Graph

SiC

Graph

Silicon Nitride

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure.

SiO₂

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and the origin figure.

Sn

Graph

Ta

Graph

Ta₂O₅

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and the origin figure.

The values by Miz13 are high compared to others.

Ti

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and the origin figure.

Xe

Graph

the complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Zn

Graph

Combining the EFSR-TCS approach with CasP brings theory close to experiment

ZrO₂

Graph

the complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

All data for O ion is here, even those not plotted yet. Here are all the origin files and the O universal plot.

₉F ions

Ag

Graph

Al

Graph

Au

Graph

C

Graph

Cu

Graph

Mo

Graph

N₂

Graph

Ni

Graph

Polycarbonate

Graph

Si

Graph

Ti

Graph

ZrO₂

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Here is the universal plot for F ions. To get the ORIGIN files for F ions, click here

All data for F ion is here, even those not plotted yet.

₁₀Ne ions

Ag

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Air

Graph

Al

Graph

Ar

Graph

Au

Graph

Discrepant Nd77 data, see paper.

C

Graph

The Po61 data appear high. Z98 lies high above Z96 and Z99.

H

Graph

He

Graph

At the maximum, the curves by Ziegler and MSTAR differ considerably, but there are no experimental points to decide.

N

Graph

Ni

Graph

Pt

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Si

Graph

TiN

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Here is the universal plot for Ne ions. To get the ORIGIN files for Ne ions, click here

₁₁Na ions

Air

Graph

Al

Graph

Ar

Graph

C

Graph

Mylar

Graph

Here is the universal plot for Na ions. To get the ORIGIN files for Na ions, click here

₁₂Mg ions

Ag

Graph

Note large discrepancy between data by At90 and Wr79, see also 2001 paper

Air

Graph

Data by Hv71 low compared to Fa68

Al

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Au

Graph

Note large discrepancy between data by At90 and Wr79, see also 2001 paper

C

Graph

Cu

Graph

Fe

Graph

He

Graph

Ni

Graph

Polycarbonate

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Si

Graph

Ta

Graph

Ti

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Here is the universal plot for Mg ions. Click here to get all the ORIGIN figures for Mg ion

₁₃Al ions

Ag

Graph

Al

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Au

Graph

C

Graph

Data by Po61 low compared to Fa66. All the curves fit the data well

Mylar

Graph

MSTAR is closer to the data than SRIM13.

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Ni

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Polycarbonate

Graph

PVC

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

SiC

Graph

Ta

Graph

Ti

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure. SRIM13 reproduces the stopping maximum better than MSTAR.

TiN

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure.

Here is the universal plot for Al ions. Click here to get all the origin figures for Al ions

₁₄Si ions

Al

Graph

For comparison, "nuclear" stopping is shown as calculated by SRIM

Ag

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Al₂O₃

Graph

Data (txt file), origin figure.

Ar

Graph

Data (txt file), origin figure.

Au

Graph

The Nd77 data appear low (see coments in 2001 paper).

C

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure The KO98 curve is surprisingly high.

Cu

Graph

GaAs

Graph

Ge

Graph

He

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Kr

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

LR-115

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Mylar

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

N2

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Nb₂O₅

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and the origin figure.

Ni

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and the origin figure.

Ne

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Polycarbonate

Graph

Polypropylene

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Experimental discrepancy around the stopping maximum

PVC

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Si

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure.

Silicon Nitride

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure.

Good agreement of SRIM13 with Ps04 and Gue16 data, BA15 values are higher than them.

SiO₂

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure.

ICRU73, SRIM, and MSTAR slightly low around the maximum.

Ta₂O₅

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), and the origin figure. Good agreement of SRIM13 with Fon16 data.

W

Graph

Zr

Graph

An universal plot for Si ions is available. To get all the ORIGIN files in compressed form click here.

₁₅P ions

Al

Graph

C

Graph

Ge

Graph

Mylar

Graph

Ni

Graph

Si

Graph

Here is the universal plot for P ions. To get all the ORIGIN files for P ions, click here

₁₆S ions

Ag

Graph

Air

Graph

Ar

Graph

Au

Graph

Note that the (high) values of Bt66 are no more mentioned by Sd75, even though both publications have a common author. See 2001 paper by Paul and Schinner

C

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure.

Cu

Graph

H₂

Graph

He

Graph

Kr

Graph

N₂

Graph

Ni

Graph

Silicon Nitride

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure.

Here is the universal plot for S ions. To get all the ORIGIN files, click here

₁₇Cl ions

Ag

Graph

Air

Graph

Al

Graph

Al₂O₃

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Ar

Graph

Au

Graph

C

Graph

H₂

Graph

He

Graph

Mylar

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

SiC

Graph

Silicon Nitride

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

N₂

Graph

Ni

Graph

Ta₂O₅

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure

Here is the universal plot for Cl ions. To get the all the ORIGIN files, click here

₁₈Ar ions

Ag

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure.

Air

Graph

Al

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure.

All the electronic stopping curves agree well with the data, except for Bar10 and libdEdx. The curve "nuclear" is the total nuclear stopping, calculated using SRIM

Ar

Graph

 The Barbui curve (Barb10) fits the data well

Au

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure.

Good experimental theoretical agreement. The Nd77 data are too low

Be

Graph

Butane

Graph

C

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure.

The low energy Trz02 data appear low. Corrected by new data Trz18. Jav12 fits well.

CF₄

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure.

CH₄

Graph

CO₂

Graph

Cu

Graph

H₂

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure. MSTAR fits well, but most of the curves (Hiraoka, Northcliffe,and SRIM) lie below the data

He

Graph

Kr

Graph

Lu

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure.

First measurements by Trz18.

Mylar

Graph

N₂

Graph

Ne

Graph

Ni

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure.

Poly carbonate

Graph

Si

Graph

Silicon Nitride

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure.

Ta

Graph

Ti

Graph

ZnP, Metaphosphate glass

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure.

Xe

Graph

The complete data table (txt file), the origin figure.

Zr

Graph

Here is the universal plot for Ar ions. Click here to get all the origin figures for Ar ions

All data for Ar ion is here, even those not plotted yet.